NEWS
Home / News / Product News / What Are The Differences between Straight Seam Steel Pipes And Spiral Steel Pipes? What Are Their Weld Types, Stress Distributions, And Selection Criteria?

What Are The Differences between Straight Seam Steel Pipes And Spiral Steel Pipes? What Are Their Weld Types, Stress Distributions, And Selection Criteria?

Views: 0     Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 2026-11-16      Origin: Site

Welded steel pipes are widely used in oil and gas transportation, water supply, construction, and industrial applications. Based on manufacturing processes and weld configurations, they are mainly divided into straight seam steel pipes and spiral steel pipes. Straight seam pipes are formed from steel plates or coils and welded along the longitudinal direction, commonly through ERW or LSAW processes, making weld inspection relatively straightforward. Spiral steel pipes, also known as SSAW pipes, are formed at a spiral angle with helical submerged arc welds, and are often used in large-diameter water transmission, piling, and infrastructure projects. The key difference lies in weld orientation: straight seam pipes have longitudinal welds, while spiral pipes have helical welds, which affects stress distribution under internal pressure. However, pipe performance depends on more than weld direction; material grade, wall thickness, manufacturing quality, welding procedures, inspection results, and applicable standards are equally important. Selection should consider required diameter, operating pressure, transportation conditions, installation environment, and project specifications. This article compares both types to help engineers and buyers choose suitable welded steel pipes.

What Are Straight Seam Steel Pipes?

Straight seam steel pipes are welded steel pipes manufactured by forming a steel plate or coil into a cylindrical shape and joining the edges along the pipe's longitudinal direction. The resulting weld runs parallel to the pipe axis—also called longitudinally welded steel pipes. Widely used in oil and gas transportation, water supply systems, industrial piping, structural engineering, and infrastructure projects.

Mainly manufactured through two common processes: Electric Resistance Welding (ERW) and Longitudinal Submerged Arc Welding (LSAW)—although both produce longitudinal weld seams, their forming methods, welding principles, and typical applications differ.

Manufacturing Process

Step

Key Activities

1. Raw material preparation

Steel coils or plates selected according to material grade, thickness, and project specifications

2. Forming

Steel material shaped into a cylindrical or tubular form using appropriate forming equipment

3. Welding

Longitudinal edges joined using ERW or LSAW technology

4. Sizing and straightening

Pipe adjusted to achieve required diameter, roundness, and dimensional accuracy

5. Inspection and testing

Welds and pipe bodies inspected according to applicable standards and customer requirements

6. Finishing

End preparation, coating, marking, and packaging before delivery

Weld Types and Characteristics

Process

Manufacturing Method

Key Characteristics

Typical Applications

ERW

Steel coils formed; edges heated by electrical resistance and pressed together; no filler metal normally used

Widely used in general fluid transportation and structural applications

General fluid transportation, structural applications, industrial piping where specified grade and standard permit

LSAW

Steel plates formed into cylindrical shapes; longitudinal joint welded by submerged arc welding (internal and external)

Suitable for large-diameter and relatively thick-walled pipes

Oil and gas transportation, water transmission, major infrastructure projects

The two processes differ in welding technology and production capabilities—buyers should select the appropriate type according to required dimensions, pressure conditions, material grade, and project standards.

Common Applications

Application Area

Typical Use

Oil and gas transportation

Suitable ERW and LSAW pipes in pipeline systems meeting API 5L grade, manufacturing, and inspection requirements

Water transmission

LSAW pipes commonly selected for large-diameter water supply and municipal pipeline projects

Structural engineering

Building structures, bridges, support columns, and other load-bearing applications

Industrial piping

ERW and LSAW pipes for different industrial fluid transportation and mechanical applications

Infrastructure and construction

Foundation engineering, piling, and other construction projects

What Are Spiral Steel Pipes?

Spiral steel pipes, also known as spiral welded steel pipes or SSAW (Spiral Submerged Arc Welded) pipes, are welded steel pipes manufactured by forming steel coils into a cylindrical shape at a specified angle and joining the edges along a helical line. Unlike straight seam steel pipes, which have longitudinal welds parallel to the pipe axis, spiral steel pipes feature weld seams that wind around the pipe body.

Widely used in water transmission, oil and gas pipeline projects where permitted, foundation piling, port construction, and other infrastructure applications—their manufacturing process provides flexibility in producing different pipe diameters from steel coils of suitable widths.

Manufacturing Process

Step

Key Activities

1. Raw material preparation

Steel coils selected according to material grade, thickness, and mechanical properties; coil edges inspected and prepared

2. Edge preparation

Steel strip edges trimmed or milled to achieve suitable dimensions and welding conditions

3. Spiral forming

Steel coil fed into forming equipment and shaped into a cylindrical pipe at a controlled spiral angle; forming angle and strip width influence pipe diameter

4. Welding

Edges joined through submerged arc welding, generally internal and external, forming a continuous helical seam

5. Cutting and sizing

Continuous pipe cut into specified lengths and adjusted to meet dimensional requirements

6. Inspection and testing

Weld seams and dimensions inspected per applicable standards; required NDT and hydrostatic testing performed as specified

7. Finishing and packaging

Pipe ends prepared, surfaces may receive protective coatings, finished pipes marked and packaged

Weld Types and Characteristics

Characteristic

Key Points

Helical weld orientation

Weld seam forms an angle with the pipe axis rather than running parallel to it

Continuous welding process

Steel coils can be continuously formed and welded, supporting efficient production

Weld inspection

Spiral seam requires appropriate inspection to verify weld integrity and compliance

Dimensional flexibility

Pipe diameter can be adjusted through forming conditions and coil width, within production equipment limits

SSAW manufacturing generally uses submerged arc welding for both internal and external sides of the joint—during welding, the arc is covered by a layer of granular flux, which helps protect the molten weld metal from atmospheric contamination.

Because the spiral seam is longer than a comparable straight longitudinal seam, weld quality and inspection planning are particularly important.

Common Applications

Application Area

Typical Use

Water transmission

Large-diameter SSAW pipes in municipal water supply, irrigation, and water diversion projects

Oil and gas transportation

Pipeline applications when manufacturing process and specifications meet applicable project requirements

Foundation piling

Steel pipe piles for bridges, buildings, ports, and marine structures

Port and coastal engineering

Structural piles and support components in waterfront and coastal construction

Industrial infrastructure

Certain low-pressure fluid transportation and structural applications

Straight Seam vs. Spiral Steel Pipes: Key Differences Compared

Straight seam steel pipes and spiral steel pipes are both widely used welded pipe products. Although they share similar basic manufacturing principles, their forming methods, weld seam orientations, production capabilities, and typical applications differ—understanding these differences helps buyers and engineering teams select suitable pipes for oil and gas transportation, water supply, foundation piling, and industrial construction.

Comparison Table

Comparison Factor

Straight Seam Steel Pipes

Spiral Steel Pipes

Weld orientation

Longitudinal

Helical or spiral

Common processes

ERW, LSAW

SSAW

Forming method

Plate or coil formed into a cylinder

Coil formed at a spiral angle

Weld seam length

Generally shorter

Generally longer

Diameter flexibility

Depends on the manufacturing process

Flexible within equipment limits

Common applications

Oil and gas, water transmission, structural use

Water transmission, piling, infrastructure

Inspection requirements

Based on applicable standards

Based on applicable standards

1. Manufacturing Process and Production Efficiency

  • Straight seam pipes – steel plates or coils formed into cylindrical shapes; edges welded along the longitudinal direction; common processes include ERW and LSAW; LSAW commonly manufactured from steel plates, ERW generally from steel coils

  • Spiral pipes – steel coils continuously formed into cylindrical shapes at a specified angle; edges joined through internal and external submerged arc welding, creating a helical seam; pipe diameter can be adjusted through forming parameters and coil width

Production efficiency depends on pipe dimensions, material thickness, equipment capacity, and manufacturing requirements—neither process is universally more efficient for every specification.

2. Weld Types and Weld Seam Distribution

  • Straight seam pipes – longitudinal weld running parallel to the pipe axis

  • Spiral pipes – helical weld winding around the pipe body at a specific angle

For the same pipe length, a spiral weld generally has a longer seam than a longitudinal weld—meaning total weld length and inspection workload may differ.

However, a longer weld does not automatically indicate lower strength or poorer quality—proper welding procedures, qualified personnel, manufacturing control, and inspection are essential for both types.

3. Stress Distribution and Mechanical Performance

Two principal stresses in a thin-walled cylindrical pipe under internal pressure:

Stress

Direction

Hoop stress

Acts around the circumference of the pipe

Longitudinal stress

Acts along the pipe axis

  • Straight seam pipe – longitudinal weld approximately parallel to the pipe axis and perpendicular to the hoop stress direction

  • Spiral pipe – helical weld crosses both principal stress directions at an angle

This difference influences stress components acting across the weld—however, actual mechanical performance also depends on steel grade, wall thickness, weld integrity, pipe geometry, residual stress, and operating conditions. Weld orientation alone cannot determine which pipe is stronger.

4. Diameter, Wall Thickness, and Dimensional Range

Pipe Type

Dimensional Characteristics

LSAW

Commonly selected for large-diameter and relatively thick-walled applications

ERW

Generally used for smaller and medium-sized specifications, depending on production equipment

SSAW

Considerable diameter flexibility—forming angle and steel coil width can be adjusted; frequently considered for large-diameter water transmission and foundation piling

Available diameter and wall thickness ranges vary by manufacturer—confirm production capabilities before placing an order.

5. Cost, Quality Inspection, and Delivery

Cost comparisons should consider more than the initial purchase price—raw material utilization, production efficiency, pipe dimensions, welding requirements, inspection costs, coating, transportation, and delivery schedules can all affect final project cost.

Quality control for both types may include:

  • Chemical composition and mechanical property testing

  • Dimensional and visual inspection

  • Weld seam non-destructive testing (NDT)

  • Hydrostatic testing

  • Material identification and traceability

Stress Distribution and Weld Performance: Which Pipe Type Is More Suitable?

Key Comparison at a Glance

Factor

Straight Seam Steel Pipes

Spiral Steel Pipes

Weld orientation

Longitudinal (parallel to pipe axis)

Helical (crosses both circumferential and longitudinal directions)

Weld interaction with hoop stress

Weld approximately perpendicular to hoop stress direction

Stress perpendicular to weld is a combination of hoop and longitudinal components

Weld length

Generally shorter

Generally longer—requires control and inspection throughout its length

Typical applications

Large-diameter, thick-walled LSAW projects; ERW for smaller/medium sizes

Large-diameter water transmission, foundation piling, infrastructure where permitted

Strength determination

Depends on material, wall thickness, weld quality, inspection, design

Depends on material, wall thickness, weld quality, inspection, design

1. Hoop Stress and Longitudinal Stress in Steel Pipes

Stress Type

Direction

Effect

Hoop stress

Circumferential direction around the pipe

Tends to split the pipe along a longitudinal line

Longitudinal stress

Parallel to the pipe axis

Tends to separate the pipe across a circumferential section

For a thin-walled cylindrical pipe under internal pressure:

  • Hoop stress ≈ PD/2t

  • Longitudinal stress ≈ PD/4t

Under these simplified conditions, hoop stress is approximately twice the longitudinal stress.

Note: actual pipeline design must consider applicable codes, wall thickness definitions, external loads, temperature, corrosion allowance, and other operating conditions.

2. How Longitudinal Welds Respond to Pipeline Stress

Straight seam pipes have welds running parallel to the pipe axis—the longitudinal weld is approximately perpendicular to the hoop stress direction.

Because hoop stress is generally the larger principal stress, the longitudinal weld requires careful control of weld integrity—any welding defects, incomplete fusion, or other discontinuities may affect pressure-containing performance.

However, modern ERW and LSAW processes can produce pipes suitable for demanding applications when products meet required manufacturing standards and inspection criteria.

3. How Spiral Welds Respond to Pipeline Stress

Spiral pipes have helical weld seams that cross both the circumferential and longitudinal directions—their orientation forms an angle with the pipe axis.

As a result, the stress acting perpendicular to the spiral weld is a combination of hoop and longitudinal stress components—the exact stress condition depends on the spiral angle and loading conditions.

The longer helical weld also requires appropriate welding control and inspection throughout its length—a longer weld does not necessarily mean lower strength, but it increases the total seam length that must be manufactured and evaluated.

4. Factors Affecting Weld Strength and Pipeline Safety

Factor

Key Points

Steel grade and chemical composition

Must provide required strength, toughness, and weldability

Wall thickness and pipe diameter

Influence pressure resistance and structural performance

Welding procedures

Proper parameters, qualified personnel, and controlled manufacturing conditions

Non-destructive testing

Ultrasonic testing, radiographic testing, and other applicable NDT methods

Hydrostatic testing

Where required, verifies ability to withstand specified test pressure

Operating conditions

Internal pressure, temperature, corrosion, external loads, and service environment

5. Which Pipe Type Is More Suitable?

There is no universal answer—straight seam and spiral steel pipes can both be suitable for pressure-bearing applications when manufactured and qualified to required standards.

  • Straight seam LSAW pipes – often considered for large-diameter, thick-walled pipeline projects with demanding dimensional and quality requirements

  • SSAW pipes – frequently selected for large-diameter water transmission, foundation piling, and other applications where their manufacturing process is permitted by project specification

For oil and gas transportation: verify compliance with applicable API 5L requirements, including permitted manufacturing process, product specification level, and project-specific acceptance criteria.

How to Choose Between Straight Seam and Spiral Steel Pipes

Selecting between straight seam steel pipes and spiral steel pipes requires a comprehensive evaluation of project requirements, operating conditions, manufacturing standards, and procurement costs. Both types have advantages, but neither is suitable for every application—the correct choice should be based on engineering specifications rather than simply comparing weld seam orientations or initial purchase prices.

Selection Factors at a Glance

Factor

What to Evaluate

Project application

Oil and gas, water transmission, foundation piling, or industrial piping; confirm permitted manufacturing process

Pipe diameter and wall thickness

ERW for smaller/medium sizes; LSAW for large-diameter, thick-walled; SSAW flexible for large diameters

Material grades and standards

API 5L, ASTM A53, ASTM A252, or project-specific standards

Cost and delivery

Raw material, manufacturing, dimensions, inspection, coatings, transportation, installation; production capacity and schedules

Quality inspection and certification

Chemical/mechanical reports, dimensional/visual records, weld NDT, hydrostatic records, MTCs, traceability

1. Select According to Project Application

Application

Pipe Options

Key Considerations

Oil and gas transportation

ERW, LSAW, or SSAW

Pipeline diameter, pressure, material grade, applicable project specifications; confirm permitted manufacturing process

Water transmission

LSAW and SSAW

Large-diameter municipal water supply, irrigation, water diversion; coating and corrosion protection

Foundation piling

SSAW and LSAW

Pile dimensions, installation methods, structural loading

Industrial piping

ERW and LSAW

Required dimensions, pressure conditions, material specifications

2. Consider Pipe Diameter and Wall Thickness

  • ERW – generally smaller and medium-sized specifications

  • LSAW – often large-diameter and relatively thick-walled applications

  • SSAW – flexible in producing different large pipe diameters by adjusting forming angle and coil width within equipment limits

Confirm before purchasing:

  • Required outside diameter and wall thickness

  • Pipe length and dimensional tolerances

  • Design pressure and expected external loads

  • Manufacturing capabilities and available specifications

The selected dimensions must satisfy engineering calculations and applicable standards.

3. Evaluate Material Grades and Applicable Standards

Standard

Main Application

API 5L

Line pipes for oil and gas transportation

ASTM A53

General-purpose welded and seamless steel pipes

ASTM A252

Welded and seamless steel pipe piles

Project-specific standards

Specialized industrial and infrastructure requirements

For API 5L pipelines: confirm required grade, PSL1 or PSL2 level, manufacturing process, and additional project requirements.
For piling applications: ASTM A252 or other specified structural requirements may apply.

Select the standard according to intended service—do not assume all straight seam or spiral pipes meet the same requirements.

4. Compare Cost and Project Delivery Requirements

Procurement decisions should consider total project costs, not just unit price.

Cost Factor

Key Points

Raw materials

Steel prices and availability

Manufacturing

Process and dimensions

Inspection

Welding and testing requirements

Surface coatings

Protective treatment costs

Transportation

Logistics and handling

Installation

Field labor and equipment

Delivery schedules also matter—confirm production capacity, material availability, inspection arrangements, packaging requirements, and transportation plans before ordering.

For large EPC projects: coordinating pipe deliveries with construction schedules helps reduce storage costs and prevent installation delays.

5. Confirm Quality Inspection and Certification

Quality control is essential for both types—before accepting an order, review required inspection and documentation arrangements.

Depending on applicable standards and project specifications:

  • Chemical composition and mechanical property test reports

  • Dimensional and visual inspection records

  • Weld seam ultrasonic or radiographic testing

  • Hydrostatic test records

  • Material test certificates and product traceability documentation

Conclusion:

Straight seam and spiral steel pipes are both widely used in oil and gas transportation, water supply, piling, structural engineering, and industrial infrastructure. Straight seam pipes, typically produced by ERW or LSAW processes, have longitudinal welds and are commonly selected for general industrial, structural, and large-diameter pipeline applications. Spiral steel pipes, also known as SSAW pipes, are formed through continuous spiral welding and offer flexible diameter production, making them suitable for large-diameter water transmission, piling, and infrastructure projects. Weld orientation affects stress distribution, but pipe performance also depends on material grade, wall thickness, welding quality, manufacturing control, inspection results, and operating conditions. Selection should be based on project requirements, including diameter, wall thickness, design pressure, steel grade, applicable standards, corrosion protection, installation conditions, quality inspection, and traceability. Buyers should also compare manufacturing costs, inspection requirements, transportation, and installation efficiency to determine the most economical solution.

FAQ:

Q1: What is the main difference between straight seam and spiral steel pipes?

Straight seam pipes have longitudinal weld seams parallel to the pipe axis, while spiral steel pipes have helical weld seams winding around the pipe body.

Q2: What are the weld types used in straight seam and spiral steel pipes?

Straight seam pipes commonly use ERW or LSAW processes. Spiral steel pipes generally use SSAW, with internal and external submerged arc welding.

Q3: How does stress distribution differ between longitudinal and spiral welded pipes?

Longitudinal welds are approximately perpendicular to hoop stress, while spiral welds cross both hoop and longitudinal stress directions at an angle.

Q4: Are straight seam steel pipes stronger than spiral steel pipes?

Not necessarily. Pipe strength depends on material grade, wall thickness, weld quality, manufacturing control, and applicable standards rather than weld orientation alone.

RELATED PRODUCTS

Providing professional one-stop procurement service for customers with excellent quality, competitive price, convenient transportation, and timely delivery.
  22nd Floor, Royal Wing Tower, Long Champ International Building, No.9 Xiangfu Road, Changsha, Hunan, China, PC:410116
  sales@threewaysteel.com
  0086-0731-8867-8598                                             

Products

Quick Links

Contact Us
About Us
Copyright © 2020 Threeway Steel Co.,Ltd. All rights reserved.